Forgot Password
Pentax Camera Forums Home
 
Log in or register to remove ads.

Showing results 1 to 4 of 4 Search: Liked Posts
Forum: Pentax Lens Articles 07-08-2009, 10:07 PM  
Beware cheap "circular" polaizers
Posted By kevindt
Replies: 34
Views: 62,642
A good polarizing filter is probably the single most useful filter for color photgraphy, and is still useful in black and white work. If used properly, it can reduce reflections from shiny surfaces, heighten sky contrast, improve foliage contrast by removing flare and double as a 2x ND filter for some situations (and two stacked linear polarizers can also make an infinitely variable ND filter).

Polarizers come mostly in two types - linear and circular polarizers.

Most normal light has a mixture of polarizations that is mostly pretty random.

Linear polarizers selectively remove that part of the light that is not polarized in the same plane as the filter. What remains and passes through to the camera lens is mostly polarized in the same plane as the filter is oriented. (that is very similar to an red filter for B/W that removes mostly green light, passing primarily red light on to the lens).

Circular polarizers are really two filters stacked one behind the other. The filter furthest from the lens is a regular linear polarizer. Immediately behind that (in the same mount) is a "quarter wave plate" oriented at 45 degrees from the polarizer. That converts the "linear polarized" light coming back from the front polarizer to "circularly polarized" light that contains all polarizations again. Just how it does it is complicated, but I can post a more in-depth article if interested.

Reflected light is partially polarized in the process of being reflected, whether it is from an object in the image that you are trying to photograph, or reflected from the beam-splitting mirror in your DSLR that allows autofocus/metering. That means, in theory at least, that feeding the camera with linearly polarized light might interfere with light metering and/or autofocus, while feeding it with circular polarized light should not. Because of this, the normal dogma is that you need a circular polarizer on a DSLR to allow autofocus and metering to work properly. In actuality here, I have found little or no problem with linear polarizers (which are often better, cheaper and less prone to other artifacts including color casts). That has been true with istD, istDS, K100D and my current K20D.

The simplest test for whether a polarizing filter is really and truly a circular polarizer is very easy. Look through it into a mirror. This is a Hoya PL-CR filter that is first held in the normal orientation (male threads toward the camera lens or my eye). Light is reflected off the mirror and passes back through. There is some darkening (about 1-2 stops with each pass through the filter) but the camera is clearly visible in the reflection. There is very little color cast visible.



Now reverse the filter. This is the same Hoya PL-CR filter with the male threads pointed to the mirror, away from the camera. Now the mirror image of the filter is very dark, making it harder to read the logo and much harder to read the lens lettering..



(Just why that happens is fairly complicated. Again, if there is interest I can post a more in-depth explanation).

If you try the same test with a good linear polarizer, there is absolutely no difference on reversing it - the image looks identical, and with minimal color cast.


Now look at a cheap Visico CPL circular polarizer bought off ebay. This is in normal orientation, male threads to camera lens.



And this is the Visico CPL reversed, female thread to the lens.



The first thing that is obvious is the lack of darkening when the filter is reversed, but there is also a definite yellow color cast in both orientations. This "circular polarizer" is only circular in shape, not in type!

This holds true for other filters I have acquired over time, some with lenses, some on their own. The Hoya 67 and 77 mm PL-CR filters are true circular polarizers with minimal color cast. The Hoya 49 and 52 mm PL are true linear polarizers, again with very little color cast. In contrast, each of the cheap Asian filters from Visico or no-name from Korea fail this simple test, both obviously as true circular polarizers and also by introducing unwanted color casts.

Try it with your own filters and see which others pass the test!
Forum: General Talk 08-30-2018, 08:03 PM  
The Joke Thread
Posted By kevindt
Replies: 5,919
Views: 496,576
A priest and a businessman went out for a round of golf.

On the first hole, the businessman sliced the ball far into the rough. "%$*@ it, I missed" was his response. The priest rolled his eyes to heaven and remained quiet.

The businessman did no better at the subsequent holes, and as his frustration increased, so did the volume of his profanity. By the 17th hole the priest could restrain himself no longer, and he told the businessman that his language was offensive to the priest and to his God.

The poor businessman took one last, futile attempt to keep his ball in play on the last hole. As he was about to give one last blasphemous cry of despair, the storm clouds rapidly gathered, the sky darkened and thunder began rolling in the heavens.

Suddenly, a gap parted in the clouds and a lightning bolt arced down to earth, striking the priest on the top of his tonsured head and killing him stone dead.

An enormous booming "%$*@ it, I missed" was heard for hundreds of miles.
Forum: General Talk 08-29-2018, 11:10 PM  
What Do Fellow Pentaxians Do For A Living?
Posted By kevindt
Replies: 171
Views: 16,758
Reminds me of when a particularly annoying 19 year old next door told me that my kids were too noisy while playing in my yard, since he was working on a major project for his very important new job. When he asked what I did for work, I told him that I pushed drugs for a living, and when things didn't work out the way I planned, people got cut up in all kinds of interesting ways.

I retired from surgery over 5 years ago, but "retired" to a full-time post in IT :)
Forum: Sold Items 07-15-2018, 03:59 PM  
For Sale - Sold: Yuzo DC 2814 Auto Macro Flash
Posted By kevindt
Replies: 13
Views: 1,885
Payment sent.

These were also sold under the Lester Dine name for dental macro-photography back when some dentists used film cameras. Lester Dine also re-packaged the excellent Kiron 105 mm f2.8 macro (also sold as Vivitar Series 1) which these attach to via the filter ring screw-thread. I have the Vivitar Series 1 version for Pentax. These two pictures were taken with that lens and one of these flashes.






Kevin
Search took 0.00 seconds | Showing results 1 to 4 of 4

 
Forum Jump


All times are GMT -7. The time now is 05:41 PM. | See also: NikonForums.com, CanonForums.com part of our network of photo forums!
  • Red (Default)
  • Green
  • Gray
  • Dark
  • Dark Yellow
  • Dark Blue
  • Old Red
  • Old Green
  • Old Gray
  • Dial-Up Style
Hello! It's great to see you back on the forum! Have you considered joining the community?
register
Creating a FREE ACCOUNT takes under a minute, removes ads, and lets you post! [Dismiss]
Top