Thanks, Tim.. The idea that it took a minute to figure out it wasn't real is really a great complement. If I can leave them wondering, then I feel I've done the job I set out to do.
I think part of the reason it got bounced was the size, too small. I've lost the original file to bad CD-ROM backups so what I have here is it. The reflection in the mirror though is actually quite small and if I remember correctly, the crop got rid of everything that didn't add to the photo. At this point I don't remember what was there on the left. I may retry one of these at a later date so I can at least get a proper size on it.